HMAS Sydney (II) Discovered
David Mearns - Search Director, The Finding Sydney Foundation
Lieutenant John Perryman, RANR – Official Observer
At 10:03 (AWDT) on Sunday 16 March 2008, a small dark shape was
detected coming into view on the starboard side of our SM30 side
scan sonar display. In an otherwise featureless seabed. David Mearns
soon classified this contact as being man-made, displaying all the
characteristics of a major shipwreck. Within minutes a debris field
came into view confirming this belief.
The wreck was measured and its position plotted in relation to the
wreck of Kormoran and what is firmly believed to be the battle site.
Our target was located approximately 10.5 nautical miles to the
south-east of the battle site and 12.2 nautical miles from Kormoran.
We soon concluded that the modified Leander class cruiser, HMAS
Sydney (II), sunk with all hands on 19 November 1941, had been found
in 2,468 metres of water. Her position was recorded as being
26° 14’ 37” S 111° 13’ 03” E.
As with the Kormoran find, news of this discovery was promptly
communicated to the Finding Sydney Foundation for on-forwarding to
the appropriate shore authorities. News of our discovery, only an
hour-following the Prime Minister’s announcement concerning the
discovery of Kormoran, was received with great emotion and
jubilation by The Finding Sydney Chairman, Ted Graham.
With a sense of euphoria onboard we immediately began to make plans
to carry out several high resolution sonar passes over Sydney’s
wreck. The first of these runs commenced at 18:35 using a 3
kilometer swathe on the SM30 side scan sonar. This run gave us the
ability to better measure the wreck and some of the larger pieces of
wreckage in the debris field. The run was completed at 18:47.
A second high resolution pass with the SM30 set to operate a 1500
meter swathe began at 23:00 and produced a good image of the wreck
lying on the seabed displaying a clear acoustic shadow. This pass
also provided an indication that part of Sydney, possibly her bow,
may have broken away from her as she limped away causing her to
sink. This is a tentative assessment which will have to be confirmed
using a suitably equipped ROV with cameras.
The dimensions of the wreck combined with its position in relation
to the wreck of Kormoran and the scene of action leave me in no
doubt that this is the wreck of Sydney. During the next few days
further high resolution runs will be conducted over her wreck and
commemorative services will be held for the crews of both Sydney and
This has been a monumental day and one which I hope will bring some
comfort to the relatives of those lost in her.
Glenys McDonald - Director, The Finding Sydney
I woke with a headache this morning. I wanted to be in the survey
room between 8am and noon as that was when we thought Sydney would
appear on our screens on this track line. The Williamson crew had
been tracking a tiny debris trail from the battle area and
indications were that this search line would be successful.
At exactly 10:03 am a large piece of wreck unfolded on the screen
with a small associated debris field. The surrounding geology was
dead flat sandy bottom. There she lay, looking proud and poignant.
HMAS Sydney had been found.
John Perryman and I had become adept students in reading the data
over the past couple of weeks and we, like David Mearns and the
Williamson and Associates crew, knew that this was what we had been
looking for. This was the ship that had taken the hopes and dreams
of 645 families to the bottom of the ocean.
Here in a relatively small area of ocean we located one ship
suffering a catastrophic explosion, a battle site, a small debris
trail, and another ship approximately ten nautical miles away
sitting proudly on the bottom, all as described by the eye witnesses
to this action between HSK Kormoran and HMAS Sydney.
There was jubilation from all, and a few tears from me. David, John
and I were thrilled. The Geosounder crew, who had become part of
this great project, joined with the Williamson team shaking hands. I
thanked the crew and Williamsons on behalf of FSF, and Geoff led a
cheer for me which was nice. I just wished that Ted and the other
Finding Sydney Foundation Directors were standing beside me.
David then rang Patrick and Ted. I spoke to Ted, and this six foot
seven inch giant of a man was overcome. We unashamedly cried
together and he asked me if I was certain. I am.
Even though we deserve our moment of jubilation after such a long
and difficult journey to this moment in time, we have not forgotten
that this was where we lost our men. I went up to the back deck and
leant over the railing and cried and gave thanks.
I believe this wreck will bring closure. She sits almost proudly on
the bottom. If Sydney had blown like Kormoran there would be little
sense of closure, but here in such a large piece and in a depth of
water where we will shortly activate the ROV part of the program, we
will give the kind of images required for everyone to finally be at
peace with this sad story.
We turned the ship around and by 18:35 we were back on site and
doing a smaller swath run. The plan is to do a few more of these
from different angles before changing the fish over to the SM60:
another long night ahead before the official announcement tomorrow.
Above Photograph - The
wreck of Sydney as revealed for the first time in this wide swathe
(6km) sonar image. The wreck is clearly visible on the port (right)
channel adjacent to a well defined debris field. The height of the
wreck above the seabed is causing the dark acoustic shadow just to
the right of the wreck.
Above Photograph - For
this second sonar track we narrowed the SM30 sonar swath to 3km and
approached the wreckage on a reciprocal course which is why the
image is reversed from above. The wreck and the debris field are
better defined in this image, but the main reason for a reciprocal
track is to help determine a more accurate position for the wreck on
Above Photograph -
Sydney 2nd Pass Zoom: This image is a repeat of the image above but
zoomed in on just the wreck and debris field. We suspect that the
large piece of debris at the lower right hand corner of the image
may be a section of the bow which broke away from the hull.
Above Photograph -
Image & Model: The third sonar track was narrowed yet again to 1.5km
and in doing so revealed the hull and debris field in the most
detail to date. Again, the large piece of wreckage at the top of the
debris field stands out as the biggest piece, other than the hull
Above Photograph -
Sydney Hull: This sonar image is a magnification of just the main
hull from the third sonar track. The acoustic shadow to the left of
the hull is used to help identify structures that have height. For
example we believe that the tallest shadow could be being caused by
Sydney’s superstructure. Careful analysis and measurements of the
hull length suggest that while the hull is sitting upright on the
seabed and is largely intact, a portion of the bow could well have
broken away and that this event was the trigger that finally caused
Sydney to sink.
Above Photograph -
Search Director, David Mearns plots the location of Sydney’s wreck
thus solving one of the most enduring maritime mysteries of the 20th
century. David is plotting the position on a Mercatorial Plotting
Sheet – the last of four he has made over a period of 5 years whilst
conducting his own manual re-navigation of the ship’s tracks and
movements during and after the battle.
Above Photograph -
David & John: A moment of delight shared by Search Director, David
Mearns and Lieutenant John Perryman, RANR knowing that the wreck of
Sydney had been found ending 67 years of uncertainty about her final